A Closer Look: Animal Law 101

Kelly Levenda
Kelly Levenda

On this edition of A Closer Look, Animal Legal Defense Fund attorney Kelly Levenda gives us a basic introduction to Animal Law. Look for a follow up post soon on careers in animal law and how law students and lawyers can get involved in this fascinating field.

What is Animal Law?

Animal law is the field of law in which nonhuman animals or their interests are involved. It encompasses all types of animals, including companion animalswildlife, and animals used in entertainmentresearch, and raised for food. Animal law intersects with many other areas of the law, including administrative, criminal, trusts and estates, constitutional, contract, and family law.

 

Hot Topics & Current Issues in Animal Law

In the last few years, many states have attempted to pass ag gag laws, which criminalize exposing animal abuse on factory farms. The Animal Legal Defense Fund (ALDF) and a broad-based public interest coalition are currently challenging the constitutionality of ag gag laws in Utah and Idaho as they infringe on the free speech rights of activists, investigators, and journalists.

Since the 2013 release of the documentary Blackfish, which critiqued SeaWorld’s imprisonment of orcas, large mammals who suffer in captivity, such as cetaceanstigers, and elephants, have come to the forefront of the public’s consciousness. Recently, Ringling Brothers and Barnum & Bailey Circus announced it would retire its elephants by 2018, in part due to new local animal protection laws that ban the use of bullhooks, weapons used to control captive elephants through pain and fear. ALDF and a coalition of nonprofits have recently succeeded in achieving Endangered Species Act protections for Lolita, the oldest living captive orca. This means that, after decades of suffering in a pathetically small tank at the Miami Seaquarium, Lolita may be able to be transferred to a sea sanctuary, or even reunited with her pod!

Legal animal advocates have also seen some successes recently in banning some forms of intensive confinement of farmed animals. Animals who are intensively confined suffer severe mental distress and physical abuse. Most notably, Proposition 2 in California, which was passed in 2008 and came into effect in 2015, prohibits the intensive confinement of egg laying hens in battery cages, mother pigs in gestation crates, and calves raised for their meat in veal crates.

Read more

Spotlight on the Animal Legal Defense Fund – Because animals have rights too!

aldf-logo-burgundyThe battle for animal rights is one often one that people don’t think about, especially if they are not a pet lover/animal enthusiast. It is because of this that an organization like the Animal Legal Defense Fund is so necessary and to get an insight on what the ALDF does I talked to Joyce Tischler, general counsel of the ALDF to fill Progressive Lawyer in on the great work this organization does.

Progressive Lawyer: Please introduce yourself and describe your role in the Animal Legal Defense Fund.

Joyce Tischler: I am Joyce Tischler, co-founder and general counsel of the Animal Legal Defense Fund. I served as ALDF’s first executive director for 25 years. For the first few years of the agency’s existence, I was the CEO, litigator, legal secretary, fundraiser, administrator, conference organizer, and facilities manager. In other words, I did everything that needed to get done, but not very well! Each time, someone has taken over a piece of my original job, I feel very successful! One of the things I’m grateful for is that my role in ALDF has been able to change and adapt as the agency has grown. Currently, I advise the CEO about internal legal matters, and handle transactional legal issues (contracts, HR issues, etc.). I also write, publish, speak and teach on a wide variety of topics related to the growing field of animal law. For additional details, here is a link to my website bio: http://aldf.org/about-us/meet-our-staff/executive-team/

PL: Why was your organization started? What issues does it confront?

JT: ALDF was started to address the legal needs of a large segment of society that lives in the shadows: nonhuman animals. Most humans consider animals as interesting, in some cases, fascinating, cute, cuddly, dangerous, etc. But, they rarely view animals as beings who are worthy of concern, or worthy of recognition of their inherent interests or needs.

We use other animals to meet a broad array of human needs and desires: we wear their body parts (fur, leather, wool, silk), eat them, exploit them in entertainment (movies, zoos, circuses), hunt and trap them, use them as companions, perform invasive medical research on them, and use them to test toxic substances, all without a lot of thought about the impacts these uses have on the animals. In fact, the negative impacts are widespread and extreme for the animals. In our society, 98% of animals live lives of frustration and pain. The largest number of animals and the greatest suffering occurs in CAFOs (factory farms). It is widely documented that, in the U.S. alone, we raise and kill ten billion animals per year. They live in horrible conditions, and are killed inhumanely. Most of us look the other way; we don’t want to know about the suffering.

ALDF was started to give animals a voice through the law; to bring their interests to the bargaining table. Over that past 36 years, ALDF has challenged a wide variety of the abuses. Please check our website for our current lawsuits and other legal projects: http://aldf.org/cases-campaigns/

Read more